I’m going to come clean: I am not a big fan of traditional ‘budgeting’ (*GASP*). You know, the thing where you have to write down everything you spend and then compare it to a pre-determined spending limit for each category of expenses (‘Did I spend more than $100 on clothes this month? Oh no, I spent $150!’ *insert guilt*).
I’ve tried it before…and it lasted a week. It’s tedious, it’s laborious and it always makes me feel bad about myself. Honestly? That’s not the kind of relationship I want to have with money.
So why does everyone talk about creating a budget then? While you don’t have to detailed budget, you should have a basic understanding of how much money you’re spending and on what. If you ever go to a financial planner, one of the first things they will do is figure out where all your money is going. This bit is REALLY IMPORTANT. Seriously. Most people have no idea where there money goes.
Okay, so how do you think people did this pre-internet, and pre-online banking? By….writing everything down. It was the only way they could keep track of what they spent. But those days are GONE. Anyone who tells you to manually write down everything you spend is living in a previous century. Seriously.
Today, thanks to technology, there are a number of budgeting apps and tracking tools that make it really easy to track your spending. It’s so easy, it can pretty much be done for you (yes, literally). So, here is a list of the best Australian budgeting and tracking apps & tools that can help you automatically track your expenses. I’ve put them into two separate categories:
- Budgeting apps that pull data from your bank accounts, therefore requiring permission to access your accounts
- Budgeting apps that do NOT pull data from your accounts, and require you to manually enter your expenses
Budgeting apps that connect with your bank account(s)
The way these tools work (very basically) is they sync to all your accounts. This means you need to give them permission to access your bank, superannuation data (and any other accounts you choose to connect) so that they can collect that all data into one place for you. Not everyone is comfortable with this — it’s a personal choice. Personally, I value the convenience and automation enough to be comfortable with this. But to provide a more balanced view, here is a popular personal finance blogger in America who doesn’t like to use such tools because of the security concern. Anyway, onto the actual tools:
This is one of the bigger and more comprehensive budgeting and tracking tools in Australia. The great thing about MoneyBrilliant (compared to other alternatives) is that they are really trying to capture your end-to-end financial picture: not just collecting your expenses from your bank transactions and credit cards, but looking at your super and your investments so that you have a complete picture of your finances. Their tool also has features that help you work towards your financial goals, and of course it has an inbuilt budget. It also helps you manage your bill payments as well. So…it’s pretty comprehensive!
AND…they have a MoneyBack Guarantee: They assert that “if we can’t find ways for you to save, or make at least the subscription fee in 12 months – we will give the money back”. That is pretty bold. I do love a good Money Back Guarantee!
It’s also worth mentioning that a few years ago, AMP bought MoneyBrilliant. Does that make it more ‘secure’ because it’s owned by a big corporate? Who knows, really.
Price: There is a free version available; to get additional features you have to pay $9.90/month
So PocketSmith is actually a New Zealand company, but they do have coverage and offerings in Australia, so I wanted to put it here.
I’d put PocketSmith above PocketBook (details below) but below MoneyBrilliant in terms of the features and comprehensive level of of analysis it is able to provide. I think the user-interface and capability of PocketSmith are really good — it allows you to create budgets, income statements and balance sheets, and it has good reporting (analysis of your money situation with charts and things). It also allows you to add in other users (e.g. if you’re a couple, or want your advisor to have access). But, it doesn’t come with some of the bells and whistles that MoneyBrilliant does (like incorporating Australian super, property, goal-setting etc).
Price: There are 3 options: free, $9.95/month, and $19.95/month — it depends on what features you want. You can always start out with the free version and upgrade, as well.
So, this one is popular with financial advisors who use it with their clients…but as an individual, it’s a bit expensive compared to other alternatives: $20/month!
I don’t know why this budgeting tool is more expensive (double the cost) of tools like MoneyBrilliant. It seems to do the same job — automatically downloads your transactions, helps you categorise them, helps you measure them against a budget, allows you to track and see your progress towards goals…all pretty standard. Their user interface is alright, not as pretty as MoneyBrilliant, but seemingly better than PocketBook.
Price: $20/month for individuals
If you want something more simple, with less frills and fancy options — Pocketbook is another Australian budgeting app that could be the way to go. This is more appropriate if you’re looking for a basic tracking and budgeting tool.
The user-interface and capability of this tool is more basic than the others mentioned above. They bring all your transactions into one place to help you see where you’re spending your money, and you can also analyze the transactions (categorise them, see pretty charts etc)…but they don’t do things like: bring in your superannuation accounts, comprehensive goal-tracking, tracking investment income etc. It does have a cool tool to help you find tax deductions though!
Price: Free to sign up. There are certain features in the tool that you need to unlock by either inviting a friend, or ‘donating’ a few dollars.
Budgeting apps that DO NOT connect with your bank account(s)
These tools are a lot more simple: instead of reading your bank transactions, they just allow you to type in all your expenses manually and use that data to provide some reports so you can easily see how much money you’re spending, and on what.
These tools do not require you to give access your accounts! Woo hoo! So if you’re a stickler for security and cannot deal with the thought of some third party looking at your bank transactions, these tools might be for you.
You Need A Budget (YNAB) is for you if you love the old school style of budgeting. It’s a great upgrade from your spreadsheet. It allows you to create a complete budget, and then you can manually enter your transactions as you go — and it will scoop all that up into neat little reports so you can see where you’re spending most of your money. It also pulls your data into income statements and balance sheets. YNAB does offer syncing with banks but it’s limited to American banks for now.
On a side note, YNAB also produce a lot of free content about money and personal finance, so check out some of their educational material. Just keep in mind that YNAB is an American company, so some of their content might be more suited to American audiences.
Price: $50/year. That’s like…less than $1/week. Not a bad deal, if you ask me!
TrackMySpend is a budgeting app created by the Aussie government. Before you automatically write it off… I’m actually pretty impressed, it’s really pretty neat.
Like YNAB, it requires manual entry. The interface and capability is a lot simpler than YNAB, but I think this is appropriate for the app. It’s not designed to spit out comprehensive or detailed income statements, it’s literally just a tool to help you write down your expenses so you can see where your money is going. If you’re really fresh to this whole budgeting and tracking thing, this could be a good place for you to ease into it.
Some banks have their own money tracking/savings/budgeting tools and apps. I know that Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) have the MySpend and NetBank tools. So, make sure you check whether your bank already offers a tool that meets your needs!
So those are the popular budgeting apps and expense tracking tools available for Australians at the moment. The initial set-up can take a bit of time (getting your accounts linked, categorising your expenses etc), but once you get in the flow of it, it becomes a lot less painful and time-consuming. Be strong, don’t give up after a week! It’ll be worth it, I promise.
Do you have experience with any budgeting or expense tracking apps or tools (whether it’s one above, or something different)? Comment below, I’d love to hear about your experiences!
* Note: This is not intended to be an exhaustive and complete review of all the services and products available on the market in this category. This blog post looks at a select number of what is available in the market. Further, the intention is not to provide a comprehensive and/or conclusive evaluation and/or ranking of products/services to determine which is ‘better’ or ‘worse’. Readers are encouraged to conduct their own independent research and obtain independent advice to determine which services would be most appropriate for their circumstances. The purpose of this post is to provide factual information, which readers may use to make their own informed decisions. We do not in any way recommend, advise or endorse any particular products and services. We do not receive commissions or payments for writing about any of these products or services.